Deconstructing the Chosen One: Tropes and Subversions in Fantasy Literature
Since time immemorial, the "Chosen One" trope has held a central place in the pantheon of fantasy narratives. This archetypal hero, often marked by birth or prophecy, embarks on a preordained journey to save the world from impending doom. While this trope has served as the backbone of countless captivating stories, it's important to acknowledge its limitations and explore the recent trend of deconstructing and subverting it in modern fantasy literature.
The Traditional Chosen One: A Familiar Hero
The traditional Chosen One is typically characterized by inherent greatness. They possess special abilities, unique destinies, and often face insurmountable challenges that they must overcome through sheer force of will and unwavering determination. This archetypal hero often embodies ideals of courage, selflessness, and a strong moral compass, offering a clear-cut figure for readers to root for.
However, this trope can become predictable and somewhat formulaic. The predetermined path of the Chosen One can limit narrative complexity and character development. Moreover, the focus on a single, exceptional individual can overshadow the contributions of other characters and diminish the sense of agency and shared responsibility in saving the world.
Challenging the Trope: Examples of Subversion
Thankfully, contemporary fantasy authors are increasingly challenging the Chosen One trope, offering a variety of subversions that enrich the genre. Here are some prominent examples:
- Anti-heroes: These morally ambiguous or even villainous characters force readers to question their loyalties and redefine their understanding of heroism. Examples include Jaime Lannister in "A Song of Ice and Fire" and Loki in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.
- Collective heroism: This approach distributes the burden of saving the world among a diverse group of characters with unique strengths and weaknesses. It emphasizes collaboration, teamwork, and the collective effort needed to overcome significant obstacles. The "Mistborn" series by Brandon Sanderson exemplifies this subversion.
- Ordinary heroes: These individuals rise to the occasion despite not being destined for greatness, demonstrating that heroism can come from anyone. Bilbo Baggins from "The Hobbit" and Frodo Baggins from "Lord of the Rings" are classic examples of ordinary heroes thrust into extraordinary circumstances.
The Benefits of Subversion: Complexity and Engagement
Deconstructing the Chosen One trope can lead to several benefits in fantasy storytelling:
- More complex characters: Subverting the trope allows for characters with flaws, doubts, and internal struggles, making them more relatable and engaging.
- Realistic challenges: When the fate of the world isn't solely reliant on a single individual, the challenges faced can be more complex and require strategic thinking and collaborative effort.
- Diverse perspectives: By moving beyond the singular perspective of the Chosen One, narratives can incorporate multiple viewpoints and explore the impact of events on different characters and communities.
The Drawbacks of Subversion: Unsympathetic Heroes and Ambiguity
While subversive approaches offer exciting possibilities, there are potential drawbacks to consider:
- Unsympathetic heroes: Anti-heroes or morally ambiguous protagonists may not resonate with readers who prefer clear-cut heroes and villains.
- Ambiguity and uncertainty: The lack of a preordained path for the hero can lead to narratives that are more ambiguous and lack the satisfying closure of traditional Chosen One stories.
Conclusion: A Spectrum of Possibilities
The evolution of the "Chosen One" trope in fantasy literature demonstrates the genre's constant innovation and adaptability. By exploring both the traditional hero and its subversions, readers can engage with a wider range of narratives and find stories that resonate with their individual preferences. Whether we root for the destined savior or celebrate the collective effort of unlikely heroes, the journey remains captivating, reminding us that the potential for greatness resides within us all.
If you are looking for an interesting read revolving around the ‘Chosen One’ trope, read ‘Searching for Zen’ by Albert T. Franklin. The book is already making headlines coming in as the #1 New Release in Religious Science Fiction and Fantasy.
Available for purchase on Amazon and other major online retailers.